Narrow Victory

Now that the war in Iraq has come to an end, we can start evaluating whether or not the results were worth the trillions of dollars spent on it. This evaluation tends to take one of two sides. Either the far left approach, which calls for an end to all wars (which still leaves me wondering whether or not Ron Paul was really a Conservative,) or the far right approach, which says that every invasion is good for America's growth and that America should be everywhere, spreading the will of the American Empire to every corner of the globe. Revolution Muslim calls it American Imperialism.

The people in the middle--those that I like to see as having at least a little bit more sense than that--do not see things as Black-and-White, cut-down-the-middle. They argue that this is humanity we're talking about, and humans are never that simple.

Still, a lot of these independent thinkers narrow the effectiveness of the Iraq war down to three things. We spent trillions of dollars, our own country is suffering because of the deficit, and we gained nothing from it. Yes: It's all about "me, me, us."

Consider the Iraq war from a survivor's perspective. Before Saddam was toppled, thousands of Shias would be killed by his regime just by him giving a command. Shias were not allowed to commemorate Ashoorah without the risk of being killed.

Now, the government in Iraq is predominantly Shia, and the rules according to Shia Islam are slowly being implemented. For instance, capitol punishment is no longer allowed, and there is a higher tolerance for other faiths existing in Iraq.

The occasional bombings we hear about from the media have their ways of making us forget what the state of Iraq used to be before the invasion. When you consider what Saddam put Shias through, compared to today's relatively low-grade attacks, I find it hard not to support the war. Does this mean it was picture-perfect, and the U.S. acted in a saintlike manner throughout the duration of the war? Certainly not. We do have reports of soldiers raping Iraqi women and committing other war crimes. But one can easily argue that Saddam was just as bad, and the freedom of Shias has greatly increased since his fall.

Lawrence Kaplan points out in his book "The War Over Iraq: Saddam’s Tyranny and America’s Mission" that there have been numerous records from Human Rights Watch of Saddam cutting off peoples' genitals and applying electric shock to them. There are also records of Saddam torturing prisoners of war during the Kuwaiti conflict by drilling holes in their chests and arms and cutting off their fingernails.

Saddam also committed mass slaughter of Shia people and made sure his Suni followers ruled with an iron fist. People used to be gassed, and there are records of him using chemical weapons against his citizens.

Consider all that compared to several people being killed in odd places or while they go on pilgrims. The latter, although not the end that everyone would like to see, is much better than how the country used to be. Further, one can argue the point that while these were Shias who were killed while traveling to the shrine of Imam Moussa Al-Kadhim (S.A,) they had indirectly accepted that sacrifice. They know there will be some possibility of them being killed by Suni insurgents, but they go anyway, driven by faith, standing proudly, and not accepting to bow to the insurgents' threat. Their freedom may not have been possible if it wasn't for the invasion. Granted, today the Arab Spring would have taken hold in Iraq, but who knew that such a thing would occur back then?

In many ways, the bombing reminds me of Ashoorah, when Imam Hussein (S.A) was killed for not bowing down to the corruption of Yazid. These Shias do the same thing, so although we should mourn them no doubt as our brothers and sisters in Islam, we should also be proud that there are Shias who will stand and go to visit these shrines and accept, with their heads held high, the possibility of being blown to bits on the way. Ask yourself this question: "Would I do it too?"
Ma'a sallamah,
Munawar